Market Paradox Explained: How Aggressive Buyers Can Coexist With Falling Prices
Positive Volume Delta means more trades were initiated by buyers, but prices can still fall if sellers absorb demand.
Caterpillar's stock fell 44% from its peak despite a record $78 billion backlog, as investors worry about a slowdown.
Caterpillar, which provides gas generators to data centres, has seen its market capitalisation fall by $214 billion since the end of June. The decline continued even as its order pipeline reached a new high of $78 billion.
According to market data, the biggest construction equipment maker worldwide closed at $600.20 on November 13, almost 44% below its all-time high. For investors, the dilemma is whether the market is anticipating a downturn that is not yet visible in the order book.
Caterpillarâs third-quarter earnings indicated robust demand. Sales and revenues climbed 17% to $20.7 billion, the company disclosed in its filing.
The Financial Times reported that power generation sales jumped 75% compared with the same quarter last year, fuelled by data centre demand.
Despite this, the stock lost 9.3% on October 29, the date the report was released. The market had anticipated an upgraded forecast, so the companyâs moderate fourth-quarter sales guidance came as a disappointment.
Fresh pressure came from the midterm elections. According to Ballotpedia, voters approved limits on data centres in 40 out of 41 local ballot measures.
AI infrastructure stocks then declined, worsening the broader selloff in AI-related trades. Benzinga reported that power and cooling equipment firm Vertiv fell 13% the day after the election.
An analysis by the Financial Times calculates losses across global manufacturing, utility and mining companies at $4.2 trillion since June.
This leaves a more challenging question about whether the backlog itself will persist.
Venture capitalist and MIT fellow Paul Kedrosky told the FT that backlogs are lagging indicators. He noted that buyers were placing duplicate orders to secure their position in the queue.
Telecom history demonstrates how quickly this can unwind. In the second quarter of 2001, major clients of Corningâs photonics unit cancelled orders they had already submitted. By September, carriers had started delaying fibre purchases, as shown in the companyâs annual filing.
Corning recorded a net loss of $5.5 billion that year and eliminated 12,000 positions. Its shares, which traded above $100 in 2000, fell to $16 by June 2001.
Nonetheless, not everyone foresees a repeat. DellâOro Group analyst Alex Cordovil told the FT that record backlogs ensure supplier revenue growth through 2027.
Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon has also backed the US data centre buildout. He cautioned that preventing it would push AI capacity abroad.
Caterpillarâs fourth-quarter results will reveal whether fresh orders continue to come in or cancellations start. Siemens, whose data centre backlog expanded by 60%, and Eaton, whose orders doubled year on year, face a similar situation.
Share to
Disclaimer: this article comes from third-party media and is provided for reference only. It does not constitute investment advice. Crypto and other financial products carry significant price volatility risk, so please make your own decisions carefully.
Positive Volume Delta means more trades were initiated by buyers, but prices can still fall if sellers absorb demand.
S&P 500 futures face resistance around 7,425 ahead of Nvidia earnings. The bearish outlook persists but buyers have a recovery path.
Ripple-backed Evernorth Holdings reported about $505 million in paper losses on its XRP holdings due to accounting rules that prevent fair-value treatment.
Major banks increased Bitcoin ETF holdings in Q3 before significant outflows. Wells Fargo led the pack.