Buy
Market
🔥
Prediction Market

US Supreme Court to rule on wagering tax for prediction market firms

The US Supreme Court will decide if prediction market operators must pay federal wagering tax on sports contracts.

13/11/2026 13:1319 min read

Robinhood, Kalshi and Crypto.com are set to learn from the US Supreme Court whether their sports contracts can avoid federal wagering tax by arguing they are not gambling operations.

These companies, which have not been collecting wagering tax on their fast-growing prediction markets, will receive a ruling on their central argument at the same time.

On September 10, Robinhood petitioned the Supreme Court to review its loss at the Ninth Circuit against Nevada's gambling commission. That case now awaits Nevada's response by December 7.

Crypto.com's derivatives unit followed on September 11 after its own loss in Nevada. Meanwhile, New Jersey, unhappy with Kalshi, filed its own petition to the Supreme Court on September 2, appealing Kalshi's Third Circuit win.

Responses in all three cases are now due on December 7.

The Supreme Court has wide latitude over when it issues rulings and has not released its winter calendar. Based on past patterns, substantive opinions typically come in December and January.

Justices also have three related cases before them that they may, but are not required to, address.

No tax collected on event contracts

Robinhood revealed in its October 28 quarterly report that it has "not collected or remitted federal excise tax on event contracts." That position is acceptable if the Supreme Court rules in its favour.

In the same SEC filing, Robinhood warned that an adverse tax ruling "could be material" and might render event contracts "uneconomical."

Most prediction market operators are fighting state regulators and making various concessions to avoid being classified as casinos or gambling operations.

Robinhood, for example, agreed on October 26 to halt new sports contracts in Ohio while its legal appeals continue, including at the Supreme Court with the December 7 deadline approaching.

The Supreme Court justices will not directly rule on the narrow issue of federal tax. However, the main case centres on Nevada's argument that Robinhood's sports prediction markets fall under state gambling laws.

If the Supreme Court sides with Nevada, it would establish strong precedent and make it tougher for Robinhood to claim its prediction markets are not bets or are tax-exempt.

Kalshi won’t let you bet on its Supreme Court outcome

Read more: Court rules prediction market Kalshi’s US election bets are legal

Supreme Court takes up Nevada prediction market challenge

Federal tax code defines a taxable wager as a bet on sports or events placed with a person or business "engaged in the business of accepting such wagers."

Prediction market operators argue that they run a marketplace where participants trade among themselves rather than betting against the house with a built-in edge, meaning they are not taking taxable wagers.

Tax researchers at New York University argued that even if federal commodities rules, like CFTC guidelines, preempt state casino or gambling laws, "it does not follow" that other federal tax laws are automatically preempted.

BREAKING: North American Derivatives Exchange (d/b/a Crypto dot com) joins Robinhood in seeking U.S. Supreme Court review of the Ninth Circuit’s decision affirming the denial of its motion for a preliminary injunction against Nevada as to sports-event contracts.

— Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL) September 11, 2026

Not collecting wagering tax is fine as long as they aren’t wagers

Robinhood acknowledged to investors that it does not collect a federal wagering tax on its prediction markets. The trading app made that disclosure in a quarterly report filed on October 28.

Robinhood stated, "We have not collected or remitted federal excise tax on event contracts offered through RHD because we do not believe these contracts are subject to such tax."

"RHD" refers to Robinhood Derivatives, the futures brokerage unit that offers event contracts.

Robinhood added that it is still assessing its exposure to those and other tax regimes, "including federal excise tax" such as sections 4401 and 4421 of the Internal Revenue Code.

Section 4401 imposes a 0.25% excise tax on wagers that the accepting state authorises.

LATEST: A bipartisan majority of US states has backed New Jersey’s petition to the Supreme Court to declare that states, not the CFTC, have authority to regulate prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. pic.twitter.com/OIldNEKWhP

— CoinMarketCap (@CoinMarketCap) October 9, 2026

A booming, ‘tax free’ industry

For context, Robinhood reported $173 million in event contracts revenue last quarter, more than six times the amount from a year earlier. Customers traded a record 16.4 billion contracts between $0.01 and $0.99 each.

On October 5, researchers at New York University’s Tax Law Center concluded that sports event contracts are probably taxable wagers.

The only factor that made their damning paper slightly less damaging was that it did not explicitly name Robinhood. Even so, the findings were as unfavourable as possible for Robinhood, Kalshi and Crypto.com.

The paper stated, "We conclude that the best reading of the code is that sports event contracts on prediction markets appear to be ‘wagers’ and ‘wagering’ and subject to the federal tax rules that apply to sports gambling.

"These include the federal excise tax on sports and contest wagers, ordinary income tax treatment for winnings, and limitations on deductions for gambling losses, among other rules."

Meanwhile, Robinhood tells its customers, "Taxes related to event contracts are your sole responsibility, including reporting on your personal tax return."

Share to

Disclaimer: this article comes from third-party media and is provided for reference only. It does not constitute investment advice. Crypto and other financial products carry significant price volatility risk, so please make your own decisions carefully.

Related articles