The White House has screened candidates for all four vacant CFTC seats, but crypto's desired outcome is not guaranteed.
Candidates for the four open Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) positions have been screened by the White House, CNBC reported. Two of the vacancies are designated for Democrats.
The law does not mandate that all seats be occupied, because the statute limits any single party to three of the five positions. At present, Chairman Michael Selig is the sole commissioner.
.@CFTC Michael Selig Sworn In as 16th CFTC Chairman: https://t.co/K2K2W5ZXTW
— CFTC (@CFTC) December 22, 2025
Between April 2022 and February 2025, all five commissioner seats were filled.
Democratic majority
Throughout his tenure, Behnam sought from Congress direct oversight of digital commodities spot markets. At the same time, his enforcement team targeted platforms that served U.S. customers without registration.
Johnson and Goldsmith Romero were the most vocal on protecting customer funds and preventing retail harm. Goldsmith Romero opposed rulemaking from the FTX era that would have allowed derivatives to be offered directly to retail investors.
Republican seats
Both commissioners consistently voted against the majority. Mersinger's dissent came in the Ooki DAO case, the first enforcement action against a decentralized organization. She detailed her objections.
Pham broke with the majority on the Uniswap settlement and proposed a supervised testing program for crypto companies.
Although they could not dictate the agenda, the crypto sector took note and brought Mersinger on in May 2025 to lead the Blockchain Association, the industry's primary Washington lobbying group.
1/ We’re pleased to announce that CFTC Commissioner Summer Mersinger has been chosen as the new Blockchain Association CEO. Summer will leave her current position as Commissioner on May 30 and will start at the Association on June 2. pic.twitter.com/gVD0B4PpdH
— Blockchain Association (@BlockchainAssn) May 14, 2025
Under the Commodity Exchange Act, five commissioners serve staggered five-year terms. Each requires Senate confirmation, and the president appoints one as chairman.
Nominees must demonstrate genuine expertise in futures trading or the underlying physical commodities—a requirement that long predates cryptocurrencies.
The party limit acts as a cap, not a minimum. A maximum of three commissioners can belong to the same party, preventing a fourth Republican but not requiring any other allocation.
Custom, not law, gives the president's party the majority. Traditionally, presidents also obtain opposition names from Senate leaders, prompting Chuck Schumer to submit a list in July.
News: Schumer has sent the White House two names each for the SEC and CFTC, people familiar with the move tell me, following months of finger-pointing over the empty seats as part of Senate negotiations over the crypto bill.
— Eleanor Mueller (@Eleanor_Mueller) July 27, 2026
The nominees' identities remain unclear: "Nobody wants…"
Both conventions can be disregarded. The law would be fully satisfied with three Republicans and two vacant seats.
Mersinger and Goldsmith Romero departed on the same date. Johnson left later that September, and Pham remained until December.
In her closing months as the only commissioner, Pham generated more crypto policy than the prior three years combined. She approved an offshore exchange access advisory in August and proposed stablecoins as derivatives collateral shortly after.
December saw the launch of a pilot for Bitcoin and ether collateral. Selig has maintained all those measures and defended his rulemaking as the sole commissioner.
The composition of the commission is less important than the White House's stance. Joe Biden's 2022 executive order characterized digital assets as a risk to be managed, while Donald Trump's January 2025 order directed agencies to embrace the technology.
The industry's ideal scenario is a mathematical one. Selig and two Republicans would form a majority, with moderates occupying the two minority seats.
Two Democrats would not be able to outvote that majority. However, they could still demand cost-benefit analyses, extend comment periods, and delay approvals for perpetual futures and margin trading.
The trade-off is what no one publicizes. A fully staffed commission is the price Senate Democrats have demanded for the CLARITY Act, which would divide digital asset oversight between the CFTC and the SEC.
In August, BeInCrypto reported that the bill's chances of passage were slim ahead of the September 15 procedural vote. A Republican involved in the legislation told CNBC that the White House probably will not fill the seats if the bill fails.
A law constrains the CFTC more strictly than any single chairman's guidance. The crypto industry is about to discover which limitation it prefers.
Share to
Disclaimer: this article comes from third-party media and is provided for reference only. It does not constitute investment advice. Crypto and other financial products carry significant price volatility risk, so please make your own decisions carefully.
Kalshi prematurely settled a Michigan vs. Western Michigan market, paying $18.6M to the wrong side before a last-second touchdown, then reversed the payouts.
Poland's third attempt to override the president's crypto law veto fell short, keeping the country as the EU's only gap in MiCA regulation.
BitMEX founder Ben Delo has donated another £4 million to the UK's Reform Party, bringing his total to £8 million. The party also faces a scandal over illegal…
The National Sheriffs' Association has dropped its opposition to the Clarity Act, shifting to a neutral stance.